Do I contradict myself?
Very well then I contradict myself,
(I am large, I contain multitudes.)
BLACK! (The fade is cute, but I think it's a little similar to your hair right now) Also, I like the starkness of the black. Bold. Fabby.
I love them both. I love the boldness of the black but I think the fade might make a better long term commitment. However you have not done black and you have done a fadeish frame before. Conclusion, you can't go wrong.
Two votes from the Jackson house for Fade.
When I first saw these pictures I immediately thought black! But the more I look at the two side by side the more I am thinking fade... They both look great! But I like the softness of the fade.
Black is bold and rather fun and cool, but Fade gets my vote for a softer look around your pretty eyes!